Crook Town AFC 3 - 3 Newcastle Blue Star - 14.11.26

A hard fought point in a thrilling contest at the Millfield.
By Harry Tindall
Blue Star were coming into this game off the back of a goalless draw at home, but it was a positive point against a strong Easington side. Crook were Blue Star’s final league opponent of the month already, so they would be hoping for another positive result going into the long break.
Crook themselves sit comfortably in mid table but picking up form with the hosts unbeaten in their last 5 matches heading into the game, securing 11 points from a possible 15.
The home side got the game underway, with Blue Star attacking the open terrace in the first half. The opening few minutes set the tone for the rest of the game with both sides’ aerial presence being tested and neither side managing to string together a sustained spell of possession.
The first chance to open the scoring fell to Crook, when Joe Bates volleyed a bouncing ball from the edge of the D, but his strike was excellently headed off the line by Joe Eggleston.
Crook closed out the opening quarter with a spell of pressure resulting in multiple corners, but Blue Star were defending well.
Against the run of play, Orrell played an immaculate over the top ball to Zych who took the ball down into his stride on the left flank, but Basey got down low to deny Zych’s shot at goal. The best chance of the game for Blue Star so far.
Moments later, Crook opened the scoring as Shields laid off Bates on the right edge of the box who capitalised from a bobble to fire hard and low across goal.
It wasn’t long before Blue Star equalised with a wonder strike from Lewis Orrell. He lined the ball up in acres of space and took a swing with his left foot from 25 yards out which flew past Basey into the top right corner. A great response and what a way to equalise.
Crook responded almost instantly, as less than a minute after Blue Star levelled the scoring, Bates doubled his tally to regain the lead for Crook. His strike from almost the same position as his earlier goal crept past the crowded penalty area and into the bottom corner.
Keen to put more of a cushion on their lead, Bates played a pass into the box from the byline but Shields’ knock towards goal was blocked well by the recovering Blue Star defence.
The momentum swung once again when MacLeod brought the ball down and found Benji Shodeinde with a well-timed through ball who was then brought down in the 18 yard area to win a penalty for Blue Star. Benji stepped up and converted from the spot to level the scoring again.
Just on the stroke of half time, Crook took the lead for the third time of the half. Shields was played over the top after a tangle between Orrell and Bates, before lobbing the ball over Anderson to put Crook back in front.
Blue Star saw themselves behind at the interval after an action packed first half.
The theme of the first half looked set to continue as Blue Star grabbed their third equaliser of the game in the opening minutes of the second. Zych battled with Hargrave on the left flank who denied the shot and knocked the ball out for a Blue Star corner. Orrell delivered and after Crook were unable to clear, Errington got on to a bouncing ball to bundle home.
After the early opening in the second half and the relentless first half, the attacking play began to slow down. The game was still all to play for, and tensions were rising after a few contested challenges led to some controversial officiating.
With ten minutes of normal play to go, Blue Star were turning to the wings to hopefully provide the winner, with Zych and Follin both proving to be a threat with their pace in behind.
There was a late chance for a Blue Star winner when substitute Liam Gribbin pounced on a loose ball but his strike on goal was no threat to Basey, much to the frustration of Zych and Benji, both of which were well placed to shoot themselves.
That was that in County Durham, a hard fought away point against an on form side. After a gripping first half, Blue Star battled well to hold on to the draw after getting an early second half equaliser.
With no game for the rest of the month, all focus turns to building on recent performances with hard work on the training pitch to put the team in good stead going into the next league game away at Bishop Auckland.
Crook Town: Basey, Niven (Scothern 84’), Beattie, Darville, Allen (Smith 84’), Hargrave, Nicholson, Haley, Shields, Bates, Eratt-Thompson
Subs not used: Thynne, Wright, Brandon
Goals: Bates (24’, 29’,) Shields 44’
Newcastle Blue Star: Anderson, Eggleston, Burke, Orrell, MacLeod, Errington (Follin 69’), Coulthard (Scott 70’), D.Anderson (Gribbin 85’), Shodeinde, McClen (Brewis 57’), Zych
Sub not used: Harrison
Goals: Orrell 28’ Shodeinde 38’(pen), Errington 54’
Date/Time: 14th November 2026 15:00 Attendance: 299
Next match: Bishop Auckland (A) 5th December 2026 15:00 – NPL Division One



Comments