Newcastle Blue Star 1-1 Billingham Synthonia (24/11/2023)

Yarm & Eaglescliffe 4-3 Newcastle Blue Star (18/11/2023)

Prudhoe YC 1-2 Newcastle Blue Star (10/11/2023)

FC Hartlepool 2-2 Newcastle Blue Star (5-4 pens) 24/10/2023

Newcastle United Under 21s 5-0 Newcastle Blue Star (18/10/2023)

Sunderland West End 1-5 Newcastle Blue Star (15/10/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 3-3 FC Hartlepool (06/10/2023)

Horden CW 0-1 Newcastle Blue Star (30/09/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 3-1 Chester-le-Street United (26/09/2023)

Brandon United 1-7 Newcastle Blue Star (23/09/2023)

Newcastle University 1-4 Newcastle Blue Star (16/09/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 0-2 Boldon CA (09/09/2023)

Chester-le-Street Town 2-2 Newcastle Blue Star (01/09/2023)

Washington FC 0-5 Newcastle Blue Star (22/08/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 5-0 Brandon United (19/08/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 3-2 Bedlington Terriers (16/08/2023)

Esh Winning FC 1-4 Newcastle Blue Star (12/08/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 2-1 Yarm & Eaglescliffe (01:08/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 2-4 Shildon AFC U21 (21/07/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 2-7 Sunderland AFC U21 (11/07/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 2-0 Ponteland United (01/05/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 0-1 Newcastle Independent (28/04/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 1-1 Burradon & New Fordley (24/04/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 5-0 Seaton Delaval (19/04/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 5-2 Killingworth (12/04/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 5-1 Newcastle Independent (08/04/2023)

Newcastle Blue Star 3-0 Seaton Delaval (29/03/2023)